Picking the right influencers can make or break your marketing campaign. Here’s what to watch out for when choosing social media influencers:
- Odd follower numbers and growth
- Low-quality comments and likes
- Gaps in posting schedule
- Past brand deal problems
- Wrong audience match
- Bad business behavior
- Limited social media activity
- Past public issues
Quick Comparison:
| Red Flag | What to Look For |
|---|---|
| Fake Followers | Sudden jumps in follower count, low engagement |
| Poor Engagement | Generic comments, low like-to-follower ratio |
| Inconsistent Posting | Long gaps between posts, erratic schedule |
| Brand Deal Issues | Deleted sponsored posts, legal troubles |
| Audience Mismatch | Followers don’t align with your target market |
| Unethical Practices | Lack of transparency, poor communication |
| Inactivity | Sporadic posts, lack of consistent content |
| Controversial Past | Public scandals, reputation issues |
Avoid these pitfalls to protect your brand and get the most from influencer partnerships.
Read more and let’s learn this in details.
Related video from YouTube
1. Odd Follower Numbers and Growth
Want to spot fake influencers? Look at their follower numbers and growth patterns. These can reveal if they’ve bought followers or engagement. Here’s what to watch for:
Follower Count Jumps
Real growth is slow and steady. If an account goes from 10,000 to 50,000 followers overnight? That’s fishy.
Engagement Doesn’t Match Followers
Good Instagram accounts get about 1.5-3% engagement from their followers. Here’s what that looks like:
| Followers | Expected Likes + Comments |
|---|---|
| 10,000 | 150 – 300 |
| 50,000 | 750 – 1,500 |
| 100,000 | 1,500 – 3,000 |
If they’re way below these numbers? Could be fake followers.
Growth Rate Red Flags
The Influencer Marketing ROI 2023 study shows average Instagram growth rates:
| Performer Type | Avg. Growth Rate |
|---|---|
| Low Performers | -0.1% |
| Medium Performers | 1.0% |
| High Performers | 3.2% |
| Instagram Average | 0.1% |
If they’re growing much faster without a good reason? That’s suspicious.
Following vs. Followers
Real influencers usually follow way fewer accounts than follow them. Fitness star Sommer Ray? 24.3 million followers, only follows 901. An account with 100,000 followers following 99,000 back? Not normal.
Why?
Because: On social media, there’s a common practice called follow-for-follow, where users follow many accounts just to get a follow back and artificially inflate their follower count.
Genuine influencers, however, don’t rely on this tactic. They build their follower base organically, meaning people follow them out of real interest in their content.
Spotting Fake Followers
- Look at follower profiles: No picture, no posts, weird username? Probably fake.
- Read the comments: Generic or off-topic? Might be bots.
- Use analytics tools: Track growth over time, spot weird spikes.
Fake influencers waste your money and can hurt your brand. Choose partners with real engagement who match your brand values.
2. Low-Quality Comments and Likes
Ever scrolled through an influencer’s post and thought, “Huh, this seems off”? You might be onto something. Low-quality comments and likes are dead giveaways when you’re trying to spot fake influencers.
Here’s the scoop: real influencers have actual fans who leave genuine comments. Fake influencers? They’re drowning in a sea of bot-generated gibberish.
Real vs. Fake Comments
Real comments are like mini-conversations. They’re specific, thoughtful, and often get a response from the influencer. Fake comments? About as exciting as watching grass grow.
Quick comparison:
| Real Comments | Fake Comments |
|---|---|
| “That blue dress is stunning! Where’d you snag it?” | “Nice pic!” |
| “Your meal prep tips saved my week!” | “Cool!” |
| “Can you show us how to do that hairstyle?” | “🔥🔥🔥” |
See the difference? Real comments show actual interest. Fake ones could be slapped on any post, anywhere.
The Like-to-Comment Ratio
Here’s a trick: check how many likes versus comments a post has. If you see 100,000 likes but only 10 comments, something’s not adding up. Industry data says a healthy engagement rate is around 5%. Anything way lower? Could be fake followers or bots at work.
Engagement Pods: The Not-So-Secret Trick
Some influencers try to cheat the system with “engagement pods”. These are groups where influencers agree to like and comment on each other’s stuff. It’s not technically fake, but it’s not real engagement either.
Marketing expert Corinne Edmiston doesn’t mince words:
“Too many brands still confuse follower counts with swaying power. It’s surprisingly easy to game the social media system, but real influence requires someone to take time to build a loyal audience.”
Spotting the Fakes
Want to catch a fake influencer in action? Here’s how:
- Look for real comments that actually relate to the post.
- Check if the influencer responds to comments. Radio silence? Red flag. Yes.
- Watch out for sudden jumps in likes or followers without a good reason.
- Use tools to calculate engagement rates and compare them to industry standards.
3. Gaps in Posting Schedule
Inconsistent posting? That’s a big red flag when you’re looking for influencers. Here’s why it matters:
Audience Engagement
Gaps in posting can make followers lose interest. It’s like a TV show that airs new episodes randomly – you might just stop watching.
Algorithm Impact
Social media algorithms love consistency. Irregular posting? Your content might get buried in followers’ feeds.
Commitment Level
Sporadic posts could mean the influencer isn’t fully dedicated to their audience or content creation.
So, how often should influencers post? Here’s a quick breakdown:
| Account Size | Followers | Posts per Week |
|---|---|---|
| Nano | 0-10K | 2 |
| Micro | 10K-100K | 3 |
| Mid | 100K-500K | 5 |
| Large | 500K+ | 12 |
Even small accounts should post twice a week. Bigger accounts? They need to post more to keep their audience engaged.
“The more consistent you are, the more your community will get to know you – which in turn builds trust and gives them a reason to engage with your content.” – Christine Colling, Social Media Manager at Later
When checking an influencer’s posting schedule, watch out for:
- Long gaps between posts
- Wildly varying post frequency
- Sudden bursts of multiple posts (especially if they’re all sponsored)
But remember: quality trumps quantity. An influencer who posts less often but creates killer content might be more valuable than a daily poster with meh content.
To assess an influencer’s posting consistency:
- Look at their posting history for the last few months
- Check if they’re consistent across different platforms
- Look for a good mix of organic and sponsored content
“If you see someone with 1 million followers with 30-100 likes on their post, it’s a clear indication they are using bots.” – Akapa Supay, Influencer Marketing Expert
Low engagement plus irregular posting? That’s a major red flag you can’t ignore.
4. Past Brand Deal Problems
Let’s talk about why you need to check an influencer’s history with other brands. It’s not just about being nosy – it’s about protecting your brand from potential disasters.
When Influencer Deals Go Wrong
Sometimes, influencer partnerships blow up in everyone’s face. Here are a couple of examples that’ll make you cringe:
The Fyre Festival Mess
Remember Fyre Festival? In 2017, it was supposed to be the event of the year. Big-name models like Bella Hadid and Kendall Jenner hyped it up. But instead of luxury, attendees got chaos.
The result? Angry customers, legal nightmares, and a bunch of influencers with egg on their faces.
“The Fyre Festival disaster shows why influencer marketing needs to be honest.” – Favikon, Marketing Expert
MrBeast’s Burger Blunder
YouTube star MrBeast thought he’d struck gold with his virtual restaurant chain. At first, it looked like a hit:
- 300+ locations
- 1 million burgers sold in just 3 months
But then things went south. Customers complained about quality, and a lawsuit popped up over trademark issues. MrBeast’s reputation took a hit, and his brand relationships got messy.
How to Avoid These Disasters
Want to steer clear of similar headaches? Here’s what to do:
- Use the Right Online Tools: That can show you an influencer’s sponsored content history and previous collaborations.
- Check Their Track Record: Look at how well their sponsored posts perform.
- Google Is Your Friend: Search for any controversies or bad press about their past deals.
- Make Sure They Fit: Do their past partnerships match your brand’s values?
Watch Out for These Warning Signs
| Red Flag | What It Means | Real-Life Example |
|---|---|---|
| Brand Hopping | They’re not loyal | An influencer promoting Coke one week, Pepsi the next |
| Deleted Sponsored Posts | They’re hiding something | Influencers erasing Fyre Festival posts after the disaster |
| Low Engagement on Ads | Their audience doesn’t trust them | Sponsored posts getting way fewer likes than regular posts |
| Legal Troubles | They don’t play by the rules | Snapchat suing Luka Sabbat in 2018 for not doing what he promised |
Protect Your Brand
Here’s how to keep your brand safe when working with influencers:
- Always Use Contracts: Spell out exactly what you expect and what happens if things go wrong.
- Ask Around: Talk to other brands that have worked with the influencer.
- Keep an Eye on Things: Regularly check the influencer’s content and how well it’s doing.
- Be Upfront: Make sure influencers clearly label sponsored content. It’s not just good practice – it’s the law (FTC rules).
5. Wrong Audience Match
Choosing a social media influencer whose followers don’t match your target market? That’s like trying to sell sunscreen in a cave. Let’s break down why audience fit matters and how to nail it.
Why Audience Fit Matters
Picture this: You’re selling high-end smartwatches, but your chosen influencer’s followers are mostly broke college students. Oops. Your message won’t stick, and your campaign might tank.
Here’s why audience fit is key:
- It gets your message to people who actually care
- It boosts engagement and conversion chances
- It gives you better bang for your marketing buck
- It keeps your brand image consistent
How to Check Audience Fit
1. Analyze Demographics
Use tools like Instagram Insights or YouTube Analytics to peek at the influencer’s audience. Look at:
- Age
- Gender
- Location
- Language
- Income level (if you can get it)
2. Examine Psychographics
Go deeper than just numbers. Check out the interests, values, and behaviors of the influencer’s followers. You can spot this in:
- Content themes that get the most love
- Comments and interactions on posts
- Other brands and influencers they follow
3. Engagement Quality Check
High engagement is great, but make sure it’s the right kind. Look for:
- Comments that show real interest
- Shares and saves (people find it valuable)
- Steady engagement across different post types
Real-World Win: Fenty Beauty
Rihanna’s Fenty Beauty launch in 2017? Pure genius in audience matching. They teamed up with diverse micro-influencers who perfectly fit their target market.
The results were HUGE:
- 1.4 million Instagram followers in just 4 days
- $100 million in sales in the first 40 days
- Named one of Time Magazine’s Best Inventions of 2017
Why did it work? The chosen influencers had followers that matched Fenty Beauty’s target: diverse, makeup-loving folks looking for inclusive beauty products.
Tools to Help You Match
Don’t guess. Use CreatorsRanks to get solid data on audience fit. CreatorsRanks is a free platform with detailed influencer profiles and audience insights (rankings and reviews included).
Final Thoughts
An influencer with millions of followers isn’t always your best bet if those followers don’t match your target market. Do your homework on audience fit. It’s what separates a campaign that flies from one that flops.
6. Bad Business Behavior
Choosing the right social media influencers is crucial. But how do you spot the bad apples? Let’s dive into some red flags that could sink your campaign and tarnish your brand.
Lack of Transparency
Ever seen an influencer post about a product without mentioning it’s sponsored? That’s a big no-no. The FTC requires clear disclosure of paid partnerships. If an influencer consistently “forgets” to mention sponsorships, they’re playing fast and loose with ethics.
Poor Communication
Communication is key in any business relationship. If an influencer takes forever to respond, misses deadlines, or sends mixed messages, it’s a recipe for disaster. These issues can derail your campaign faster than you can say “Instagram story.”
Controversial Content
Politics and conspiracy theories might get clicks, but they’re risky business for brands. An influencer who’s always stirring the pot might end up burning your brand in the process.
Overselling
You know that friend who’s always trying to sell you something? Annoying, right? The same goes for influencers. If their feed looks like a non-stop infomercial, your brand message might get lost in the noise.
“Influencers who are known for posting mostly branded or sponsored content risk having your brand lost in the fray.” – Hollywood Branded
Fake Followers and Engagement
Some influencers pump up their numbers with fake followers and bot engagement. It’s like paying for a billboard in a ghost town – a waste of your marketing budget.
Here’s what to watch out for:
| Red Flag | What It Looks Like |
|---|---|
| Sudden follower spikes | Follower count jumps by thousands overnight |
| Low engagement rates | 100K followers but only 50 likes per post |
| Generic comments | “Great post!” on every single photo |
| Inconsistent engagement | One post gets 5K likes, the next gets 50 |
Legal Issues
An influencer with a rap sheet? That’s a hard pass. Remember the Twitch creator charged with inciting a riot in 2019? That’s the kind of drama your brand doesn’t need.
Lack of Professionalism
A professional influencer should have their ducks in a row. If they can’t provide a media kit with basic info like demographics and engagement rates, they might not be ready for the big leagues.
The Cost of Bad Behavior
Partnering with shady influencers isn’t just embarrassing – it’s expensive. A study by CHEQ and the University of Baltimore found that influencer fraud could cost brands up to $1.3 billion annually. That’s billion with a B.
Protect your brand by:
- Doing your homework on potential influencers
- Using tools to sniff out fake followers (Instead of complex or expensive analytics tools, simply use the rankings on CreatorsRanks.com, where trust-worthy creators are carefully ranked)
- Keeping an eye on performance and engagement
- Having iron-clad contracts that spell out what’s okay and what’s not
7. Limited Social Media Activity
An influencer’s social media activity can make or break your campaign. Here’s why it matters:
Posting Frequency Matters
Check out these stats:
| Posting Frequency | Engagement Rate | Follower Growth |
|---|---|---|
| Less than once a week | 8% | Slowest |
| Once per day | 7% | 4x faster |
| More than once per day | 7% | Fastest |
Surprised? Daily posters grow their audience WAY faster, even with slightly lower engagement rates.
Red Flags to Watch For
- Big gaps between posts
- Random bursts of activity
- No clear posting schedule
These could mean the influencer isn’t all-in on their online presence.
The Real Deal or Just Faking It?
Limited activity often goes hand-in-hand with iffy authenticity:
- They might say yes to any partnership
- They struggle to connect with followers
- Their posts feel forced
“Spotting real influencers is key for marketing agencies looking to get the most bang for their buck and protect their reputation.” – Digital Retail Partners
Watch Out for Fraud
Limited activity might be hiding something:
- Half of marketers can’t spot fake followers
- 63% have dealt with fake influencers
- Up to 50% of sponsored engagement could be fake
An inconsistent schedule might be covering up inflated numbers or bots.
What You Should Do
- Look at their last few months of posts
- Check if people are actually engaging
- Is their content any good?
- Look at all their social platforms
For Instagram marketing, go for influencers who post daily. It’s not just about numbers – it’s about building a real community.
8. Past Public Issues
An influencer’s history can make or break your brand. Let’s look at how to spot red flags and protect your reputation.
Why History Matters
Teaming up with an influencer who has a shady past? It can blow up in your face. Check out these stats from Influencer Marketing Hub:
| Issue | Percentage |
|---|---|
| Marketers who’ve had influencer marketing flops | 70% |
| Marketers worried about reputation damage | 40% |
Yikes. Ignoring an influencer’s background is clearly a gamble.
Real-Life Reputation Disasters
1. Kim K’s Crypto Mess
In 2022, Kim Kardashian got hit with a $1.26 million fine from the SEC. Her crime? Promoting EthereumMax without mentioning her $250,000 paycheck. Ouch.
2. Liver King’s Big Lie
Brian Johnson (aka “Liver King”) built his brand on “ancestral living.” Plot twist: In 2023, it came out he was juicing with steroids. His credibility? Toast.
3. Kusha Kapila’s Bully Problem
Comedian Kusha Kapila got caught up in a cyberbullying scandal in 2023. Turns out, she’d been harassing another social media personality. The fallout? Massive backlash and brands jumping ship.
Dodging the Reputation Bullets
Want to avoid these nightmares? Here’s how:
- Do Your Detective Work
Before you shake hands with an influencer:
- Dive into their content history
- Check out their engagement patterns
- See how they talk to their followers
- Stay Sharp
Once you’re working together:
- Keep tabs on their activity
- Use tools to track your brand mentions
- Watch for any warning signs
- Cover Your Bases
Put escape clauses in your contracts. If things go south, you need an exit strategy.
Digital marketing guru Lilach Bullock nails it: “Digital marketing knowledge should be accessible to all.”
That includes knowing when to cut and run from a problematic influencer.
The Bottom Line
An influencer’s past issues can be a ticking time bomb. Do your homework, stay alert, and you’ll dodge the reputation disasters that sink other brands.
Conclusion
Picking the right social media influencers can make or break your marketing campaign. Here’s a quick rundown of what to watch out for and how to build solid partnerships:
Red Flags to Watch When Choosing Social Media Influencers
Watch out for these warning signs when vetting influencers:
- Weird follower numbers? Might be fake followers.
- Engagement looks off? Could be a bot-driven audience.
- Posting schedule all over the place? Shows they’re not committed.
- Past brand deals gone wrong? That’s a reputation risk.
- Audience doesn’t match yours? You’re wasting money.
- Shady business practices? Your brand could take a hit.
- Barely any social activity? They might be hiding something.
- Caught up in public drama? You don’t want that association.
How to Do Your Homework on Influencers
1. Check if the audience fits
Make sure the influencer’s followers match who you’re trying to reach.
2. Look at engagement
Aim for about 3% engagement. That’s a good benchmark.
3. Is their content any good?
Look for authentic stuff that fits your brand vibe.
4. See how they’ve worked with brands before
Have they done well with other partnerships?
5. Make sure they follow the rules
They need to be clear about sponsored content. It’s the law.
Tips for Working Well with Influencers
- Pick influencers who actually like your stuff. It shows.
- Sometimes smaller, niche influencers pack a bigger punch.
- Let them be creative. Don’t try to control everything.
- Think long-term. Ongoing partnerships often work better than one-offs.
- Be clear about what you want from the start.
Digital marketing knowledge includes knowing how to pick and work with influencers. It’s not just about who has the most followers. It’s about finding the right fit for your brand and building a partnership that works for both of you.
FAQs
How do you spot a fake influencer?
Spotting fake influencers isn’t rocket science. Here’s what to look out for:
Sudden follower jumps? Red flag. If someone gains thousands of followers overnight, something’s fishy.
Check the engagement. Tons of followers but crickets in the comments? That’s a no-go.
Look at the comments themselves. If they’re all “Nice pic!” or “Cool!”, bots might be at work.
Posting schedule all over the place? Real influencers stick to a routine.
And if they’re only on one platform? That’s weird. Most influencers spread their wings across multiple sites.
“Fake influencers? They’re just burning your cash and potentially trashing your brand.” – Shane Barker, Digital Marketing Consultant
How to know if a brand collab is legit?
Want to avoid shady brand deals? Do this:
1. Google is your friend: Search the brand. If nothing comes up, that’s suspicious.
2. Numbers don’t lie: Check their followers and engagement. Do they match up?
3. Contact info check: Can you easily find ways to reach them? Good sign.
4. News and scam alerts: Any bad press or scam warnings? Run for the hills.
5. Ask for receipts: Get references from past collabs. Legit brands will have them.
6. Get it in writing: Ask for a detailed agreement. No contract? No deal.
7. Face-to-face (sort of): Set up a video call. Scammers hate showing their faces.
Oh, and if they ask you to pay for shipping? It’s a scam. Full stop.
“If a brand wants you to pay ANYTHING upfront, walk away. Shipping costs, partial payments, promises of refunds – it’s all BS.” – Eni Given Sunday, Influencer and Content Creator
How do you know if a collab is real?
Sniffing out fake collabs is easier than you think:
Check that email address. If it’s not @brandname.com, be skeptical.
If the offer sounds too good to be true… well, you know the rest.
“Dear @username” or “Hey Sweetheart”? Delete. Real brands use your actual name.
No social media presence or website? Major red flag.
And trust your gut. If something feels off, it probably is. “Don’t fall for these scams, folks. If you’re trying to make it as an influencer, your time will come. Just be patient.” – Thrifts and Tangles